Navigating the Digital Dilemma: A Framework for Tech Wellness in Our Schools
Written by: Krista Weber,Jacob Hauck
If you’ve been in education long enough, you might remember schools before screens. But the truth is, we’re raising and teaching a generation that has never known a world without technology for an increasingly digital future. As educators, we witness the tension between the innovation that technology offers and the growing toll it can take on student mental health. Our challenge is not to turn away from technology, but to navigate what can feel like the “messy middle” – that space where we cultivate both digital literacy and emotional wellness.
The Research and Reality of the Digital Dilemma
The statistics on youth mental health paint a stark picture. In the last decade, rates of anxiety and depression among teenagers have risen sharply. According to the CDC, the percentage of high school students who reported persistent feelings of sadness or hopelessness climbed from 28% in 2010 to over 40% by 2021.1 This increase coincides with the rise of social media and digital access.
While correlation is not causation, a growing body of research suggests a clear link between heavy technology use and mental health challenges. The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt (2024) suggests multiple reasons for this dynamic:
– The Comparison Trap: When young people spend hours on digital platforms, they often “trade genuine human connection for curated lives and relentless comparison.”2 This digital reality can amplify insecurity, anxiety, and isolation in students, as they create a culture of comparison and isolation during the identity-forming teenage years.
– Sleep Disruption: Screen use, especially before bed, interferes with the body’s natural production of melatonin, the hormone that helps induce sleep. Teens who get less than eight hours of sleep each night experience a negative impact on their mood, focus, and mental health.2
– Neurological Impacts: Excessive screen use negatively affects attention spans, emotional regulation, an increased need for dopamine, lagging social skills, and exposure to inappropriate content.2
This research stands in contrast to the reality that teens today spend an average of over seven hours a day on screens – and that’s not counting schoolwork. However, technology is also an invaluable tool. It facilitates connection, helps students find communities where they belong, and makes learning engaging. As Haidt reminds us, “Social media can be a tool for connection or a trap of comparison. The choice is ours.”2 Our role as educators is to guide them toward the right choice.
“We are preparing students for a world that runs on technology, but we must also safeguard their well-being.”
Strategies for the Classroom: Modeling the “Messy Middle”
Given the overwhelming body of research combined with our current digitized reality, we must learn to embrace the “messy middle” of the digital dilemma by integrating digital wellness practices directly into our educational culture. Our role is to teach students how to use technology in a way that respects their developing brains and their emotional health.
- Teach Digital Wellness as a Core Skill
Digital wellness should be treated with the same importance as other health education. This involves teaching students actionable strategies for taking control of their digital lives:
- Limit Notifications: Those pings and buzzes are designed to grab attention and keep us scrolling. Mute non-essential notifications to reclaim control over your time and focus.
- Teach and Model Healthy Screen Time Boundaries: Anne Lamott’s wisdom applies equally to our students: “Almost everything will work again if you unplug it for a few minutes…including you.”
- Check out these Digital Wellness videos created by Creston Intermediate & Middle School Counselor Jacob Hauck:
- Build in Intentional Tech-Free Time
Digital detoxes don’t have to be extreme. They can be small, consistent practices that give the brain a break. Consider implementing “tech-free” times during the school day, such as a phone-free policy during lunch or a dedicated portion of class time for reflection or face-to-face discussion without student devices. Research cited in The Anxious Generation found that teens who took a one-week break from Instagram felt less anxious and more positive. The goal is to teach students that healthy boundaries bring control and balance.
- Prioritize Face-to-Face Connection and Critical Thinking
Not all screen time is created equal. We must consistently guide students to choose meaningful interactions over endless scrolling.
- Re-emphasize Social Skills: Structure group activities that require active listening, non-verbal cue reading, and collaboration to help students rebuild lagging social skills.
- Quality over Quantity: Teach students to ask: “Am I using my phone to connect with friends, learn something new, or create something cool? Or am I just scrolling out of habit?”
“Teach students to ask: ‘Am I using my phone to connect with friends, learn something new, or create something cool? Or am I just scrolling out of habit?’”
Building a Community of Wellness
Our responsibility extends beyond the classroom walls. Finding balance requires a partnership between schools and homes.
- Provide Education: Schools can offer resources and education to parents, staff, and students tailored to developmental milestones and mental health. This could involve hosting PTO meetings on digital citizenship, book studies or recommendations (The Anxious Generation, Unselfie), garnering support for the Wait Until 8th pledge, and integrating Digital Literacy and Wellbeing materials from organizations like Common Sense Media. Additionally, schools can use these Counselor Connect resources to facilitate book studies on The Anxious Generation.
- Focus on Emotional Regulation: Explicitly teach strategies for emotional regulation that are not dependent on instant digital gratification. By providing non-screen-based outlets and coping mechanisms, we prepare students to handle distress in a healthier way.
We are preparing students for a world that runs on technology, but we must also safeguard their well-being. We live in the tension between research and reality, recognizing both the opportunities and the challenges of an ever-evolving digital world. By deliberately modeling and teaching digital wellness, we help students find the balance necessary to thrive in this “messy middle” of the digital dilemma.
Resources
1Center for Disease Control and Prevention. (2023). Youth Risk Behavior Survey Data Summary & Trends Report: 2011–2021. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
2Haidt, J. (2024). The anxious generation: How the great rewiring of childhood is causing an epidemic of mental illness. Penguin Press.
Please login or register to claim PGPs.
Alternatively, you may use the PGP Request Form if you prefer to not register an account.
